Is not Calno like Carchemish?
The phrase "Is not Calno like Carchemish?" invites us to explore the historical and geographical context of these ancient cities. Calno, also known as Calneh, was a city in northern Mesopotamia, often associated with the Assyrian Empire's expansion. Carchemish, on the other hand, was a significant Hittite city located on the Euphrates River, known for its strategic importance and its eventual conquest by the Assyrians. The rhetorical question posed here by the prophet Isaiah is meant to highlight the Assyrian king's arrogance and his belief in the inevitability of his conquests. Historically, both cities fell to Assyrian power, symbolizing the empire's might. This comparison serves as a reminder of the transient nature of earthly power and the ultimate sovereignty of God over nations.

Is not Hamath like Arpad?
The mention of "Hamath" and "Arpad" continues the theme of Assyrian conquests. Hamath was a prominent city in Syria, known for its wealth and influence, while Arpad was a smaller city-state that also fell to Assyrian dominance. The Hebrew root of Hamath suggests a "fortress" or "citadel," indicating its strength and fortification. Arpad, though less prominent, was strategically important. The rhetorical question underscores the Assyrian king's pride in his military achievements, yet it also serves as a prophetic warning that such pride precedes a fall. In a broader theological context, this comparison reminds believers of the futility of relying on human strength and the importance of trusting in God's eternal power.

Is not Samaria like Damascus?
The comparison of "Samaria" and "Damascus" brings the focus closer to the heart of Israel and Judah's concerns. Samaria was the capital of the Northern Kingdom of Israel, while Damascus was the capital of Aram (Syria). Both cities were significant in the biblical narrative, often representing centers of political and spiritual rebellion against God. The Hebrew root for Samaria implies "watchtower," symbolizing vigilance but also isolation. Damascus, with its rich history and cultural influence, was a city of great importance in the ancient Near East. By equating these cities, the Assyrian king boasts of his ability to conquer even the most fortified and significant places. However, from a conservative Christian perspective, this serves as a reminder of God's ultimate judgment against pride and the assurance that His plans will prevail over human ambitions. The verse calls believers to reflect on the sovereignty of God and the assurance that, despite human arrogance, God's purposes will be fulfilled.

(9) Is not Calno as Carchemish?--The six names obviously pointed to more recent conquests in which Sargon and his predecessors had exulted. One after another they had fallen. Could Judah hope to escape? (1) Calno, the Calneh of Genesis 10:10, Amos 6:2. That prophet had held up its fate in vain as a warning to Samaria. It has been identified by Kay with Ctesiphon on the east bank of the Tigris, by Lenormant (Manual, i. 80) with Ur of the Chaldees and with the ruins known now as the Mugheir, by Rawlinson (Five Great Monarchies, i. 20) with Nipur. The Assyrian form, Kil-Anu, means the "house" or "temple" of Anu, an Assyrian deity). Sennacherib (Lenormant i. 398), speaks of having reconquered it after a Chaldean revolt, and sold its inhabitants as slaves. The LXX. version, which instead of naming Carchemish, gives "Calane, where the tower was built," seems to imply a tradition identifying that city with the Tower of Babel of Genesis 11:4. (2) Carchemish. Few cities of the ancient world occupied a more prominent position than this. Its name has been explained as meaning the Tower of Chemosh, and so bears witness to the widespread cultus of the deity whom we meet with in Biblical history as the "abomination of the Moabites" (1Kings 11:7). It has been commonly identified with the Circesium of Greek historians, but the inscriptions found by Mr. George Smith at Tarabolos (the Hierapolis of the Greeks) on the banks of the Euphrates, at its junction with the Kyabur, prove that this is the true representative of the great commercial city of the old Hittite kings (Times, Aug. 23, 1876). Its importance is shown by the frequent occurrence of the name, in its Egyptian form of Karakumusha, in the record of Egyptian kings. Thothmes I. (circa B.C. 1600) conquered it, and, as a result of his campaign, strengthened the forces of Egypt with the chariots and horses for which it was afterwards conspicuous (Lenormant, Manual, 1 p. 229). Thothmes III. built a fortress there to guard the passage of the Euphrates (ibid. 1 p. 232), the ruins of which, with Egyptian inscriptions and works of Egyptian manufacture, have recently been found there (ibid. 1 p.,263). It revolted against Ramses II. (the Sesostris of the Greeks), with the Hittites and Ph?nicians, and other nations, but was subdued by him in the expedition in which the victorious issue is recorded on the monument on the Nahr-el-Kelb near Beyr-t. Shalmaneser IV. (contemporary with Ahab) records that he demolished and burnt it (ibid. 1 p. 380). Tiglath-pileser II., the king to whom Ahaz paid tribute, received tribute from its king in B.C. 742 (ibid. 1 p. 389). The last two victories are probably referred to in the boast now before us. At a later period it was conspicuous for the great defeat of Pharaoh Necho's army by Nebuchadnezzar (see notes on Jeremiah 46:2). Its commercial importance is indicated by the fact that the "mana (Heb., manah) of Carchemish" appears in numerous cuneiform inscriptions as the standard weight of the time, just as that of Troyes, in the commerce of the Middle Ages, is shown by the survival of the name in the "Troy weight" of our arithmetic books (Records of the Past, vii. 114).

Is not Hamath as Arpad?--(1) Hamath on the Orontes, the capital of an Aramaean kingdom, was prominent in the history of the East. Under its kings Toi and Joram it paid tribute to David (2Samuel 8:9-10). It fell under the power of Jeroboam II. of Israel (2Kings 14:25). In conjunction with Damascus it revolted against Shalmaneser IV., and was subdued by him (Lenormant's Manual, 1 p. 380). Its king was first among the tributary princes under Tiglath-pileser II. after having joined with Pekah and Rezin in their revolt (ibid. 1 p. 389). Lastly, to come to the date of the present prophecy, it again revolted, in conjunction, as before, with Damascus and Samaria, and was again subdued by Sargon (ibid. 1 p. 393). (2) Of the early history of Arpad we know less, but it appears as having sustained a three years' siege from the forces of Tiglath-pileser II. It joined Hamath in its revolt against Sargon, and was again, as this verse implies, subdued by him. It is always united in the Old Testament with Hamath (Isaiah 36:19; Isaiah 37:13). Under the name of Erfad it is still traceable about nine miles from Aleppo (Lenormant, 1 pp. 389, 393). . . .

Verse 9. - Is not Calno as Carehemish? A further proof of superiority, and ground of confidence, lay in the further fact, that the strongest cities had, one and all, succumbed to the Assyrian arms, and been laid in ruins to punish them for offering resistance. Six such cities are mentioned - Calneh, probably Niffer, in Lower Mesopotamia; Carchemish, on the right bank of the Euphrates in Lat. 36° 30' nearly; Hamath, the "great Hamath" of Amos (Amos 6:2), in Coelesyria on the routes; Arpad, perhaps Tel-Erfad, near Aleppo; Damascus, and Samaria. Calneh was one of the cities of Nimrod (Genesis 10:10), and, according to the LXX., was "the place where the tower was built." It may have been taken by Tiglath-Pileser in one of his expeditious into Babylonia. Amos (Amos 6:2) speaks of it as desolate in his day. Carchemish (Assyrian Gargamis) was a chief city of the Hittites, and has been called "their northern capital." Long confounded by geographers with Circesium at the junction of the Khabour with the Euphrates, it has recently been proved to have occupied a far more northern position, and is now generally identified with the ruins discovered by Mr. George Smith at Jerabis or Jerabhs. It was conquered by Sargon in B.C. 717, when "its people were led captive, and scattered over the Assyrian empire, while Assyrian colonists were brought to people the city in their place; Carchemish being formally annexed to Assyria, and placed under an Assyrian governor" (G. Smith, 'Assyria,' p. 97). Hamath was originally a Canaanite city (Genesis 10:18). By the time of David it had become the scat of an independent monarchy (2 Samuel 8:9, 10), and so continued until its reduction by the Assyrians. We find it leagued with the Hittites, the Syrians of Damascus, and the Israelites against Assyria about B.C. 850 ('Ancient Monarchies,' vol. 2. pp. 361-363). About B.C. 720 it was taken by Sargon, who beheaded its king, and probably reduced it to ruins (ibid., p. 411; comp. Amos 6:2). The name remains in the modern Hamah, where many curious inscriptions have been recently dug up. Arpad was attacked by Tiglath-Pileser in the early part of his reign, and reduced to subjection. It revolted in conjunction with Hamath from Sargon, and was severely punished ('Ancient Monarchies,' l.s.c.). Is not Samaria as Damascus? This mention of Samaria among the subjugated and ruined cities may undoubtedly be prophetic; but the connection with Carchemish, Hamath, and Arpad all of them towns reduced by Sargon within the years B.C. 720-717 - points rather to the verse being historical, and would seem to indicate that the date of the entire prophecy - vers. 5-19 - is subsequent to the capture of the cities, and so not earlier than B.C. 716.

Parallel Commentaries ...


“Is not
הֲלֹ֥א (hă·lō)
Adverb - Negative particle
Strong's 3808: Not, no

Calno
כַּלְנ֑וֹ (kal·nōw)
Noun - proper - feminine singular
Strong's 3641: Calneh -- a place in Babylon

like Carchemish?
כְּכַרְכְּמִ֖ישׁ (kə·ḵar·kə·mîš)
Preposition-k | Noun - proper - feminine singular
Strong's 3751: Carchemish -- a city on the Euphrates

Is not
לֹ֤א (lō)
Adverb - Negative particle
Strong's 3808: Not, no

Hamath
חֲמָ֔ת (ḥă·māṯ)
Noun - proper - feminine singular
Strong's 2574: Hamath -- a place North of Damascus

like Arpad?
כְאַרְפַּד֙ (ḵə·’ar·paḏ)
Preposition-k | Noun - proper - feminine singular
Strong's 774: Arpad -- a city in Aram (Syria)

Is not
לֹ֥א (lō)
Adverb - Negative particle
Strong's 3808: Not, no

Samaria
שֹׁמְרֽוֹן׃ (šō·mə·rō·wn)
Noun - proper - feminine singular
Strong's 8111: Samaria -- capital of northern kingdom of Israel

like Damascus?
כְדַמֶּ֖שֶׂק (ḵə·ḏam·me·śeq)
Preposition-k | Noun - proper - feminine singular
Strong's 1834: Damascus -- a city in Aram (Syria)


Isaiah 10:9 NIV
Isaiah 10:9 NLT
Isaiah 10:9 ESV
Isaiah 10:9 NASB
Isaiah 10:9 KJV

Isaiah 10:9 BibleApps.com
Isaiah 10:9 Biblia Paralela
Isaiah 10:9 Chinese Bible
Isaiah 10:9 French Bible
Isaiah 10:9 Catholic Bible

OT Prophets: Isaiah 10:9 Isn't Calno like Carchemish? Isn't Hamath like (Isa Isi Is)