Why have you forsaken me? Definition and Context In Scripture, the phrase “Why have You forsaken Me?” originates from Psalm 22:1 and appears again in Matthew 27:46 and Mark 15:34 in the words of Jesus on the cross: “My God, My God, why have You forsaken Me?” This expression reflects an intense moment of anguish. It is rooted in Old Testament prophecy of the Messiah and points to the depth of Jesus’ suffering. The circumstance of forsakenness is not merely an emotional experience but encompasses the fulfillment of messianic prophecy. Many scholars across Church history have viewed this statement as central to understanding the purpose of the crucifixion. It shows Christ, fully divine yet fully human, undergoing the penalty of sin on behalf of humanity (Isaiah 53:4–5). By referencing Psalm 22, Jesus demonstrates that His role on the cross aligns precisely with Scripture’s prophetic claims. Biblical Background of Forsakenness 1. Psalm 22 Prophecy: David’s lament, “My God, My God, why have You forsaken me?” (Psalm 22:1), foreshadows the suffering Servant, later fulfilled in Christ’s crucifixion. The psalm describes vivid details, such as the piercing of hands and feet (Psalm 22:16) and the casting of lots for clothing (Psalm 22:18)—elements confirmed in the Gospel accounts (Matthew 27:35; John 19:24). 2. Covenantal Framework: In covenantal language, forsakenness can imply divine judgment upon sin. Yet Scripture teaches that Jesus, who was without sin (Hebrews 4:15), willingly bore the sins of the world (2 Corinthians 5:21). In taking mankind’s transgressions, He experienced the righteous judgment due to sinners, momentarily revealing the darkness of separation caused by iniquity. 3. Messianic Fulfillment: The Gospels repeatedly acknowledge Old Testament prophecies fulfilled in Christ’s life, death, and resurrection. The common thread of messianic expectation in passages like Isaiah 53 and Zechariah 12:10 reflects the same theme of redemptive suffering, culminating in Jesus’ atoning work on the cross. The Theological Significance 1. Substitutionary Atonement: Christ’s cry of forsakenness underscores the cost of redemption. Galatians 3:13 states that “Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us.” This has been taught by theologians throughout history: Jesus took on humanity’s guilt, shouldering its consequence. 2. Bridging of Holiness and Grace: The holiness of God cannot coexist with sin, so sin must be judged. Jesus’ sense of forsakenness indicates the reality of divine wrath fully placed on Him (Romans 3:24–25). At the same time, through God’s grace, believers gain fellowship with Him, as that penalty is paid (Ephesians 1:7). 3. Divine and Human Nature of Christ: Jesus’ anguished words reveal His genuine human experience of suffering. While fully divine (John 1:1), He also bore real human sorrow—this theological tension illuminates the fullness of God’s saving plan. Historical and Manuscript Evidence 1. New Testament Consistency: Early manuscripts, such as those preserved at the Chester Beatty Library and the Bodmer Papyri, confirm the reliability of Matthew 27 and Mark 15. The textual evidence aligns in multiple Greek manuscripts, suggesting the authenticity of Jesus’ utterance. 2. Support from the Dead Sea Scrolls: While the New Testament text itself is not in the Dead Sea Scrolls, these ancient Hebrew and Aramaic manuscripts support the preservation of Old Testament prophecies like Psalm 22, confirming the texts that Jesus quoted from. 3. Archaeological Corroboration: Discoveries such as the 1968 find of a crucified man in Jerusalem—Yehohanan—shed light on Roman crucifixion methods described in the Gospels. These details illustrate the historical plausibility of how Jesus would have been crucified and why His reference to Psalm 22 points to genuine suffering. Apologetic Considerations 1. Messianic Prophecy and Fulfillment: Studies by historians and apologists, including analyses of David’s psalms and Isaiah 53, highlight the improbability of multiple prophecies aligning by chance. Such fulfillments point strongly to divine orchestration rather than random coincidence. 2. Rational Defense of the Resurrection: The anguish of Christ’s forsakenness is inseparable from His victory three days later. Detailed research into the empty tomb (including the work of thinkers like Gary Habermas), the numerous post-resurrection appearances, and the transformative effect on the disciples supports the claim that Jesus rose bodily from the grave. 3. Consistent Manuscript Transmission: Comparisons between ancient manuscripts demonstrate remarkable consistency in conveying this pivotal statement from the cross. Scholars studying textual variants hold that none alter core doctrines—in fact, the exact cry “My God, My God, why have You forsaken Me?” is solidly attested. Interpretations and Pastoral Reflections 1. Identification with Human Suffering: Believers find comfort knowing that the Son of God intimately understands grief. The hallmarks of Christ’s passion help those who feel abandoned see that they have a high priest who empathizes with them (Hebrews 4:15–16). 2. Encouragement in Times of Trial: Because Jesus overcame separation through His resurrection, His followers are assured they will not be ultimately forsaken (Matthew 28:20). This promise offers hope amid life’s darkest storms. 3. Invitation to Trust: Still today, individuals confronted by moments of despair can see in Jesus’ words the echo of Psalm 22’s final resolution—ultimately, God’s purpose triumphs and leads to deliverance, making the cry a gateway to deeper faith rather than endured hopelessness. Scriptural Applications 1. Spiritual Examination: Reflect on areas of life where sin might be separating one from the holiness of God. The reality of Jesus’ forsakenness invites a sober awareness of sin’s destructive power. 2. Worship and Gratitude: The heart of the Christian message is that Jesus bore the separation we deserved. Such truth fosters humility, worship, and gratitude (Romans 11:33–36). 3. Proclamation of the Gospel: The statement of forsakenness, fulfilled and resolved in Christ’s resurrection, forms the powerful core of the good news. Sharing this hope underscores the urgency and depth of God’s redemptive plan. Conclusion Jesus’ cry, “Why have You forsaken Me?” stands at the heart of the redemptive drama. With divine prophecy in Psalm 22 setting the stage, the Gospel accounts confirm its ultimate fulfillment when the innocent One willingly bore the world’s guilt. Beyond the details of historical verification and manuscript evidence, this phrase addresses universal human anguish and points to the solution God Himself provided: atonement through the self-sacrifice of the Messiah. Ultimately, the cry of forsakenness emphasizes that, for a moment, Jesus experienced what sin had wrought for humanity so that believers would never be eternally forsaken. The sorrow of the cross leads to the joy of the resurrection, confirming hope and salvation in the One who overcame death. |
    |