How do we reconcile the mass killing commanded in this chapter with the Bible’s teachings on mercy (Joshua 6:21)? 1. Understanding the Text of Joshua 6:21 Joshua 6:21 states, “At the edge of the sword they completely destroyed everything in the city—man and woman, young and old, oxen, sheep, and donkeys.” This verse describes the conquest of Jericho and the destruction of all living beings within its walls. Readers often ask how such severe judgment can align with the broader scriptural teachings on mercy, grace, and compassion. The question centers on reconciling two powerful themes in Scripture: God’s holiness (which demands judgment against sin) and God’s mercy (which offers compassion and redemption). Exploring the context of Joshua 6 within the entire biblical narrative sheds light on how these themes harmonize. 2. The Context of Judgment and the Canaanite Culture Throughout Scripture, divine judgments—even severe ones—stem from a purpose consistent with God’s character. In the case of the Canaanites, the biblical narrative includes warnings about their pervasive moral corruption: • Deuteronomy 18:9–12 describes how the Canaanites engaged in sorcery, divination, and child sacrifice. • Genesis 15:16 suggests that God postponed Israel’s entry into the land: “For the iniquity of the Amorites is not yet complete.” This indicates that centuries passed before judgment fell upon the Canaanite nations, implying God’s long-suffering and patience. Ancient records, including various archaeological findings, emphasize pervasive idolatrous practices in Canaan. Some sites show evidence (such as elevated sacrificial platforms and remains of infant burials) consistent with the biblical depiction of child sacrifice. The scriptural understanding is that the depth of Canaanite wickedness had reached a point of requiring decisive judgment. 3. Harmonizing Mercy and Judgment A prominent difficulty in reconciling Joshua 6:21 with divine mercy arises if these judgments are viewed purely through a modern lens, absent the recognition of God as Creator and ultimate Judge. Scripture teaches that: • God has rightful authority as the Giver of life (cf. Psalm 24:1). • God is also described as “compassionate and gracious, slow to anger and abounding in loving devotion and truth” (Exodus 34:6). In Jericho’s case, the call for destruction was not capricious. Rahab and her household were shown mercy (Joshua 6:25), signifying that individuals who turned to God could escape judgment. The story highlights both God’s justice on persistent evil and His compassion, extended to those who repent. 4. Theological Considerations of God’s Holiness Scripture underscores that God is perfectly holy, which means sin cannot remain unaddressed. Comparing narratives of judgment throughout the Bible (such as the Flood in Genesis 6–9 and Sodom and Gomorrah in Genesis 19) reveals a consistent theme: • God issues warnings and provides opportunities for repentance. • Persistent rebellion invites divine judgment. • Acts of judgment in Scripture often prevent widespread evil from corrupting future generations. Though the language of “completely destroy” is undeniably severe, it also situates itself within the biblical worldview that places God as sovereign over life and death. From that perspective, any act of judgment flows from His holiness and ultimate right to judge sin. 5. Ancient Warfare Context and Hyperbolic Language Many scholars who study ancient Near Eastern literature note that language of total destruction often employed a rhetorical device. Phrases such as “man, woman, young and old” commonly appeared in documents of that period to signify a decisive, overwhelming victory. While there was undoubtedly real warfare and loss of life, the phrasing could be hyperbolic, emphasizing victory against a hostile power rather than intending to detail each person’s fate exhaustively. Additionally, archaeological work at Tel es-Sultan (the site of ancient Jericho) indicates the city was heavily fortified. Scholars like Dr. Bryant Wood have argued for a destructive event consistent with the biblical timeframe and description. This intersection of biblical text and archaeological data affirms the historical reality of the conquest. Yet the principle remains that the biblical language carries a rhetorical dimension common to ancient world accounts. 6. Grace Amid Judgment: The Example of Rahab Rahab’s rescue exemplifies God’s willingness to spare those who trust Him. Joshua 6:25 records, “And Joshua spared Rahab the prostitute with her family and all who belonged to her, because she had hidden the spies whom Joshua had sent to Jericho.” Here, despite Jericho’s sentence, genuine faith offered a path of salvation. This moment underscores a biblical motif: where there is repentance or acknowledgment of God, mercy is always extended. Thus, the story of Jericho simultaneously discloses the severity of rejecting God and the mercy available to those who turn to Him. 7. God’s Progressive Revelation and Redemptive Plan The conquest of Jericho marks a transitional point for Israel entering the Promised Land. Far from an isolated act of violence, it fits within a cosmic battle between good and evil unfolding in Scripture. The broader biblical message is: • Humanity, left to its own devices, gravitates toward sin (Romans 3:23). • God’s covenant and redemptive plan aim to bless the world through His people and ultimately through the promised Messiah (Genesis 12:3; Galatians 3:8). • Judgment scenes throughout the Old Testament foreshadow the ultimate salvation offered through Christ’s atoning work on the cross, revealing both God’s justice and grace. This movement of salvation history leads to the redemptive arc culminating in Christ’s resurrection—a testament to God’s power over sin and death. 8. Addressing Modern Ethical Concerns For many readers today, violence of any magnitude raises moral and ethical questions. Several points can help bridge these ancient texts with modern sensibilities: 1. Divine Foreknowledge and Authority: Only God, who knows all hearts, can judge righteously. Human courts often sentence individuals based on partial knowledge; God sees the entirety of human rebellion and the destructive influence of sin over generations. 2. Timing and Long-Suffering: Scripture explicitly states God delayed this judgment until the iniquity of the Canaanites reached its full measure (Genesis 15:16). This underlines His prolonged patience beforehand. 3. Opportunity to Repent: Rahab’s case and many portions of Scripture show that if any Canaanite recognized the truth of God, they had an opportunity to turn to Him (cf. Joshua 2:8–14). Judgment was not indiscriminate but designed to confront entrenched, destructive wickedness. 4. God’s Redemptive Ends: The Israelite conquest aimed to establish a nation set apart to reflect God’s righteousness. In the progressive revelation of Scripture, this sets the stage for the coming of the Messiah who offers salvation to all nations. 9. Consistency with the Broader Biblical Witness Across the Bible, these foundational truths recur: • God judges evil: Noah’s Flood, Sodom’s demise, and Jericho’s fall showcase that entrenched wickedness ultimately faces accountability. • God extends mercy: The institutions of sacrifice in the Old Testament and, ultimately, Jesus’s sacrifice in the New Testament reveal God’s desire for reconciliation with humankind. • God is sovereign: He alone has the moral prerogative to judge nations, knowing the root causes of moral corruption and precisely when it must be halted. • Human responsibility: Scripture calls every person to repent and receive mercy (Ezekiel 18:32; Acts 17:30). 10. Conclusion: Judgment and Mercy in the Grand Narrative Joshua 6:21 addresses a historical event that reflects God’s character as both just and merciful. Although modern readers may struggle with the intensity of this ancient warfare account, viewing it within the contexts of: • The moral degeneration of the Canaanite culture, • The gracious rescue given to those who believed, and • The entire narrative of God’s redemptive plan, reveals that the same God who permits judgment on sin also extends profound mercy to the repentant. This reality is most powerfully expressed in the ultimate sacrifice and resurrection of Christ—fulfilling the themes of justice and mercy in Scripture. In this way, the mass killing commanded in Joshua 6:21 stands neither as an isolated nor contradictory event, but as part of a larger tapestry revealing God as holy, just, and abundantly merciful to all who turn to Him. |
    |