If humans truly held dominion over creation (Psalm 8:6–8), why have animals and nature often prevailed over humans historically, such as through natural disasters or pandemics? Dominion in Scripture Psalm 8:6–8 declares: “You made him ruler over the works of Your hands; You have placed everything under his feet: all sheep and oxen, and even the beasts of the field, the birds of the air and the fish of the sea, all that swim the paths of the seas.” These verses affirm a special responsibility given to humanity over creation. The question then arises: if humans were truly granted such dominion, how do we account for historical evidence of nature’s overpowering force, such as natural disasters, pandemics, or encounters with dangerous animals? Below is a comprehensive exploration of how Scripture, theological perspectives, and historical realities align to show how humanity’s intended dominion exists even amid the brokenness evident in the natural realm. 1. The Original Mandate and Its Scope Genesis 1:28 states, “God blessed them and said to them, ‘Be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth and subdue it; rule over the fish of the sea and the birds of the air and every creature that crawls upon the earth.’” This verse, along with Psalm 8:6–8, is foundational to the concept of human dominion. Dominion, as depicted here, involves responsible oversight, stewardship, and care of the earth rather than exploitation. In these passages, humans are seen as the pinnacle of God’s earthly creation. The original design was a harmonious relationship between people and the rest of creation, reflecting God’s own care and order. Outside sources, such as various ancient Near Eastern texts, sometimes present humanity in servitude to deities for menial ends. By contrast, the biblical viewpoint elevates humans as God’s stewards, echoing His creative nature by cultivating and overseeing the created order. 2. The Interruption of Harmony: The Fall Despite the mandate for stewardship, Scripture (Genesis 3) records an event that fractured the relationship between humanity and the rest of creation: the entrance of sin into the world. Genesis 3:17–19 reveals how creation itself would be subjected to difficulty: “Cursed is the ground because of you; through toil you will eat of it all the days of your life.” This condition extends beyond mere agricultural challenges. Romans 8:20–22 later builds on this idea, noting that “the creation was subjected to futility” and “the whole creation has been groaning together in the pains of childbirth until the present time.” These scriptural statements frame natural disasters, disease, and the hostility of wildlife as part of a fallen order that was not the original state but a result of the wider corruption inflicted on creation by humanity’s rebellion. From an observational standpoint, it is consistent that in a fallen world, viruses, pandemics, and geological upheavals would signal a disruption of the peace God initially intended. Peer-reviewed scientific studies of pathogens, for example, note that they often mutate and adapt in ways that increase harm rather than aid in a perfectly balanced ecosystem. Geological evidence, interpreted within a young-earth creation perspective, points to cataclysmic events (such as massive worldwide flooding layers that many researchers see as corroborating a global Flood as recorded in Genesis 6–9), suggesting that these destructive occurrences are further signs of a creation currently under strain. 3. Why Nature Sometimes “Prevails” Even though humans have displayed extraordinary ingenuity—cultivating land, taming certain animals, creating modern technologies—nature can still appear to overpower. Scripture does not deny the potency of natural forces; rather, it includes multiple accounts of storms, plagues, and famine overwhelming entire populations (e.g., the plagues in Exodus 7–12). Historical illustrations abound. Ancient pandemics like the Antonine Plague or medieval catastrophes like the Black Death claimed countless lives. In modern times, events from the 1918 influenza pandemic to more recent outbreaks still confound the best human efforts. Earthquakes, hurricanes, volcanic eruptions, and tsunamis remind us of the immense power the creation wields. A biblical perspective recognizes that a moral and spiritual disruption also corrupted nature’s relationship with humanity. Consequently, we see examples—both scriptural and extra-biblical—of nature’s unbridled power causing suffering. While humans maintain a God-given capacity to innovate and exercise partial management, the complete and unrestrained dominion intended in the pre-Fall condition is no longer fully realized in our current world. 4. The Continuing Significance of Stewardship Although creation exhibits turmoil, humanity’s role remains one of responsible governance and stewardship under God. The biblical ideal of dominion should encourage ethical treatment of animals, compassion for the environment, and wise use of resources. The notion of dominion is not a license for chaos or harm to the earth; rather, it calls for accountability. Modern examples include research and conservation efforts that help protect endangered species and restore ecological balance. These undertakings can be seen as echoes of humanity’s dominion role. Though incomplete due to the world’s broken state, these measures reflect the ongoing responsibility to care for what was entrusted to us. Additionally, various archaeological and historical records reveal that even in ancient times, societies sought to maintain order, develop agriculture, and systematically manage resources. Clay tablets from Mesopotamian civilizations, for instance, mention irrigation techniques and legal frameworks around farmland. These point to a recognition of humanity’s need to harness and organize the natural world. In modern contexts, such stewardship is furthered by technological advances like drilling wells in desert regions or employing genetic research to increase crop yields, all indicating traces of the “dominion mandate.” 5. Factors Demonstrating Caution and Humility While Scripture teaches dominion, it also repeatedly underscores humility before the Creator. In the Book of Job, God challenges Job with a series of questions about the untamable aspects of nature—behemoths, leviathans, and weather phenomena (Job 38–41). These passages remind us that our authority over the natural world is derived and limited. It was granted by God, yet it comes with accountability and depends on our fidelity to the One who grants it. Historical data show that pride or hubris often leads to mismanagement, poor stewardship, or reckless approaches to nature. The eruption of Mount Vesuvius in AD 79 and related attempts by local authorities to interpret signs from the environment highlight that, despite achievements, humanity can still be caught unprepared. Hence, dominion must be balanced with the humility that acknowledges nature’s strength and God’s sovereign control. 6. The Role of Redemption and Restoration Though creation is currently subject to problems, Scriptural teaching offers hope. Romans 8:19–21 indicates, “The creation waits in eager expectation for the revelation of the sons of God. For the creation was subjected to futility… in hope that the creation itself will be set free from its bondage to decay and brought into the glorious freedom of the children of God.” The redemptive work of Christ brings not only personal salvation but also a future promise that the entire created order will be renewed. The resurrection of Christ, historically documented in multiple early manuscripts (including partial accounts within first-century writings such as 1 Corinthians 15, attested by several reliable Greek manuscripts and supported by eyewitness testimonies noted by authors like Josephus and Tacitus), is the definitive guarantee of this cosmic renewal. As believers hold to the eyewitness accounts of the resurrection—testimonies that remain consistent across ancient documents—there is confidence that God will one day restore both humanity and creation. This future restoration will include the full and proper exercise of humanity’s dominion, as initially intended. 7. Miraculous Examples of Dominion Restored Scripture recounts instances where God’s power, channeled through individuals, provided glimpses of this renewed dominion. From miraculous healings (Luke 5:12–26; Acts 3:6–10) to authority over destructive weather events (Mark 4:39), these events underscore the coming reality of perfectly restored dominion. There are also modern testimonies—corroborated by various medical professionals in anecdotal case studies—of otherwise unexplainable recoveries or healings that some attribute to divine intervention. While these accounts differ in their documentation, they align with the principle that God retains ultimate dominion and occasionally demonstrates it through miraculous means. 8. Practical Implications and Living Out Dominion Today In light of these truths, the question of why nature sometimes appears to prevail can be answered with several practical takeaways: 1. Recognition of a Fallen Condition: We live in a world marred by sin and corruption, so the full extent of our God-given dominion remains compromised until final restoration. 2. Responsibility in Stewardship: Despite challenges, we are still called to serve as caretakers. Advances in science, medicine, environmental care, and technological innovation are partial fulfillments of subduing the earth—always balanced by accountability before God. 3. Humility and Dependence: Acknowledging God’s sovereign control prepares us to accept that while dominion is given, it is not absolute in this life. Preparation, vigilance, and moral responsibility help mitigate natural catastrophes and disease outbreaks. 4. Hope for Complete Renewal: The resurrection of Christ stands at the center of confidence that one day dominion will be wholly restored. Scripture points toward a time when creation “will be set free from its bondage to decay” (Romans 8:21). 9. The Forward-Looking Conclusion Although human history includes countless accounts of pandemics, natural disasters, and animal attacks, these do not contradict the biblical teaching of dominion. Rather, they fit within the broader context of a world that has strayed from its original perfection. The dominion granted to humanity remains real but is hindered by the effects of sin. Through responsible stewardship and acknowledgment of God’s sovereignty, humanity continues to exercise aspects of that dominion even in a fallen world. Ultimately, the hope of complete reconciliation through Christ points to a day when the curse will be lifted, and humanity’s beneficial reign—intended from the beginning—will be fully realized. “Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth,” declares Revelation 21:1, forecasting the ultimate restoration in which dominion is held rightly, without any of the tragedies that currently beset creation. Until that day, we live in the tension: called to steward the earth, mindful of our limitations, and forever looking forward to the grand renewal promised by the One who made all things. |
    |