Circumcision: Necessity of, Denied by Paul
Jump to: Torrey'sLibrarySubtopicsTerms
Topical Encyclopedia
Circumcision, the physical act of removing the foreskin of the male genitalia, holds significant religious and cultural importance within the Jewish tradition. It is a covenantal sign given by God to Abraham, as recorded in Genesis 17:10-14, marking the Jewish people as set apart for God. This rite was a critical aspect of Jewish identity and religious observance, symbolizing the individual's inclusion in the community of God's chosen people.

In the early Christian church, the necessity of circumcision became a contentious issue, particularly as the Gospel spread to Gentile (non-Jewish) populations. The Apostle Paul, a key figure in the early church and a former Pharisee, addressed this issue directly in his epistles, arguing against the necessity of circumcision for salvation and inclusion in the Christian community.

Paul's primary argument against the necessity of circumcision is rooted in the doctrine of justification by faith. In his letter to the Galatians, Paul writes, "Mark my words! I, Paul, tell you that if you let yourselves be circumcised, Christ will be of no value to you at all" (Galatians 5:2). Here, Paul emphasizes that reliance on the physical act of circumcision undermines the sufficiency of Christ's sacrifice and the grace received through faith. He further asserts, "For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision nor uncircumcision has any value. All that matters is faith, expressed through love" (Galatians 5:6).

Paul's stance is not an outright rejection of circumcision as a cultural or traditional practice but rather a denial of its necessity for salvation. In Romans 2:28-29, he articulates a deeper understanding of circumcision, stating, "A man is not a Jew because he is one outwardly, nor is circumcision only outward and physical. No, a man is a Jew because he is one inwardly, and circumcision is a matter of the heart, by the Spirit, not by the written code" . This spiritual interpretation shifts the focus from external observance to internal transformation, aligning with the new covenant established through Jesus Christ.

The Jerusalem Council, as recorded in Acts 15, further solidified the position that circumcision was not required for Gentile converts. The council, which included Paul, Peter, and other early church leaders, concluded that imposing the Jewish law, including circumcision, on Gentile believers was unnecessary. Instead, they emphasized abstaining from practices associated with idolatry and immorality, thus affirming the sufficiency of faith in Christ for salvation.

Paul's teachings on circumcision reflect a broader theological shift from the old covenant, based on the law, to the new covenant, centered on grace and faith. His letters to the Galatians, Romans, and Corinthians consistently highlight the transformative power of the Gospel, which transcends cultural and ritualistic boundaries. By denying the necessity of circumcision, Paul champions the inclusivity of the Gospel message, affirming that salvation is available to all who believe, regardless of their adherence to Jewish customs.
Torrey's Topical Textbook
Galatians 2:3-5
But neither Titus, who was with me, being a Greek, was compelled to be circumcised:
Torrey's Topical Textbook

Library

The Necessity of Other Preparatory Acts Besides Faith
... that the Catholic doctrine of the necessity of good ... that 'in Christ Jesus neither
circumcision availeth anything ... on Luther, since he bluntly denied free-will ...
/.../pohle/grace actual and habitual/section 2 the necessity of.htm

The Epistles of St. Paul
... not be required to submit to circumcision and the ... who laid on no Gentile the necessity
of adopting ... They no longer denied that uncircumcised Christians were ...
/.../pullan/the books of the new testament/chapter viii the epistles of.htm

Paul in Ephesus.
... "But he confessed and denied not, but ... But, there seems to be no necessity for so
identifying the ... our Saviour to his Church to supply the place of circumcision. ...
/.../dick/lectures on the acts of the apostles/lecture xxii paul in ephesus.htm

The Epistles of Paul.
... public assemblies (chaps.11, 12, 14), and some among them denied the doctrine of ...
where, being a Greek, he was exempted from the necessity of circumcision. ...
/.../barrows/companion to the bible/chapter xxx the epistles of.htm

Peaceable Principles and True: Or, a Brief Answer to Mr. D'Anver's ...
... tell us of your last, 'you never denied that baptism ... The rule was ordinary; which
was circumcision; the laying ... it, is clear, and you must of necessity grant it ...
/.../the works of john bunyan volumes 1-3/peaceable principles and true or.htm

The Conversion of Paul.
... he took revenge and attacked the circumcision, the sabbath ... and resulted at last,
by logical necessity, in an ... the very possibility of which is denied as being ...
/.../history of the christian church volume i/section 31 the conversion of.htm

The Conservative Reaction, and the Liberal victory --
... He unwittingly again denied his Lord from the fear of ... did, of course, not demand
the circumcision of the ... He never dreamed of denying the necessity and efficacy ...
/.../section 35 the conservative reaction.htm

The Gospel According to St. Luke
... of Christ's real Divinity and an insistence upon the necessity of circumcision for
all ... Peter "Satan," or that Peter cursed and swore when he denied Christ. ...
/.../pullan/the books of the new testament/chapter v the gospel according.htm

Homilies on Galatians and Ephesians.
... Circumcision, brings us under the Law, [179]37; observed ... Necessity, not to be pleaded
in excuse for sin ... Novatians, denied repentance to the lapsed, [432]25 (note ...
/.../homilies on galatians and ephesians.htm

Elucidations.
... of sacrifice, (3) the rainbow, (4) circumcision, (5) the ... of the Ante-Nicene Fathers
a necessity for the ... fearing towards their divinities, will not be denied. ...
/...//christianbookshelf.org/clement/the stromata or miscellanies/elucidations 5.htm

Resources
Why do some cultures practice female genital mutilation (FGM)? | GotQuestions.org

What are the bodily discharges mentioned in Leviticus 15, and why did they make a person unclean? | GotQuestions.org

Summary of the Book of Colossians - Bible Survey | GotQuestions.org

Circumcision: Dictionary and Thesaurus | Clyx.com

Bible ConcordanceBible DictionaryBible EncyclopediaTopical BibleBible Thesuarus
Subtopics

Circumcision

Circumcision was Performed by Persons in Authority

Circumcision was Performed by the Heads of Families

Circumcision was Performed in the Presence of the Family

Circumcision was Performed with Knives of Flint

Circumcision was Performed: Even on the Sabbath Day

Circumcision was Performed: On Males Home-Born and Bought

Circumcision was Performed: On the Eighth Day

Circumcision without Faith, Vain

Circumcision without Obedience, Vain

Circumcision: A Designation of Christians

Circumcision: A Designation of the Jews

Circumcision: A Painful and Bloody Rite

Circumcision: A Prerequisite of the Privileges of the Passover

Circumcision: A Seal of Righteousness

Circumcision: A Seal of the Covenant

Circumcision: Abolished by the Gospel

Circumcision: Abraham

Circumcision: Abrogated

Circumcision: Accompanied With Naming the Child

Circumcision: Called The: Circumcision in the Flesh

Circumcision: Called The: Concision

Circumcision: Called The: Covenant of Circumcision

Circumcision: Characterized by Paul As a Yoke

Circumcision: Child Named at the Time of

Circumcision: Covenant Promises of

Circumcision: Described

Circumcision: Enforced by the Law

Circumcision: Figurative

Circumcision: First Performed on Abraham and his Family

Circumcision: Instituted by God

Circumcision: Institution of

Circumcision: Introductory Jewish Ordinances

Circumcision: Inward Grace

Circumcision: Israelites at Gilgal

Circumcision: Jesus

Circumcision: John the Baptist

Circumcision: Moses

Circumcision: Necessary to Enjoying the Privileges of the Jewish State

Circumcision: Necessity of, Asserted by False Teachers

Circumcision: Necessity of, Denied by Paul

Circumcision: Necessity of, Falsely Taught by Judaizing Christians

Circumcision: Neglect of, Punished

Circumcision: Neglected

Circumcision: Not Performed in the Wilderness

Circumcision: Outward Sign of

Circumcision: Paul

Circumcision: Paul Denounced for Opposing

Circumcision: Paul's Argument Against the Continuance of

Circumcision: Performed by Joshua at Gilgal

Circumcision: Performed on all Males on the Eighth Day

Circumcision: Performed on Timothy As a Matter or Expediency Because of The

Circumcision: Promises to Abraham Previous To

Circumcision: Punishment for Neglecting

Circumcision: Purity of Heart

Circumcision: Purity of Speech

Circumcision: Readiness to Hear and Obey

Circumcision: Rite of, Observed on the Sabbath

Circumcision: Saints the True Spiritual

Circumcision: Shechemites

Circumcision: Sometimes Performed on Slain Enemies

Circumcision: The Jews: Denominated By

Circumcision: The Jews: Despised As Unclean Those not of The

Circumcision: The Jews: Held It Unlawful to Intermarry With Those not of The

Circumcision: The Jews: Held No Intercourse With Those not of The

Circumcision: Timothy

Circumcision: Trusting To, a Denial of Christ

Related Terms

Uncircumcision (19 Occurrences)

Underwent (22 Occurrences)

Foreskin (12 Occurrences)

Uncircumcised (48 Occurrences)

Circumcised (58 Occurrences)

Concision (1 Occurrence)

Reckoned (98 Occurrences)

Credited (19 Occurrences)

Value (138 Occurrences)

Counts (15 Occurrences)

Profit (143 Occurrences)

Undergo (91 Occurrences)

Knife (10 Occurrences)

Keeps (154 Occurrences)

Undergoes (11 Occurrences)

Law-transgressor (2 Occurrences)

Transgressor (9 Occurrences)

Rules (160 Occurrences)

Counted (122 Occurrences)

Avail (15 Occurrences)

Real (26 Occurrences)

Opposite (137 Occurrences)

Proselyte (2 Occurrences)

Seal (47 Occurrences)

Performed (110 Occurrences)

Jew (34 Occurrences)

Desolation (131 Occurrences)

Keeping (282 Occurrences)

Though (623 Occurrences)

Agreement (341 Occurrences)

Party (47 Occurrences)

Quite (55 Occurrences)

Keepest (16 Occurrences)

Undergone (20 Occurrences)

Outward (17 Occurrences)

Law-breaker (3 Occurrences)

Literal (2 Occurrences)

Letter (112 Occurrences)

Group (32 Occurrences)

Workers (76 Occurrences)

Importance (9 Occurrences)

Footsteps (30 Occurrences)

Families (272 Occurrences)

Receiveth (48 Occurrences)

Receives (43 Occurrences)

Removal (42 Occurrences)

Equally (21 Occurrences)

Eight (81 Occurrences)

External (8 Occurrences)

Example (54 Occurrences)

Doer (25 Occurrences)

Profiteth (9 Occurrences)

Profits (19 Occurrences)

Practise (52 Occurrences)

Breaker (2 Occurrences)

Circumcise (13 Occurrences)

Accounted (32 Occurrences)

Attacked (93 Occurrences)

Advantage (44 Occurrences)

Availeth (6 Occurrences)

Simply (27 Occurrences)

Steps (113 Occurrences)

Sign (181 Occurrences)

Boy (94 Occurrences)

Benefit (39 Occurrences)

Existence (35 Occurrences)

Galatians (2 Occurrences)

Practice (71 Occurrences)

Break (257 Occurrences)

Christian (41 Occurrences)

Won't (144 Occurrences)

Responsible (242 Occurrences)

Justus (3 Occurrences)

Rule (291 Occurrences)

Bloody (19 Occurrences)

Nature (80 Occurrences)

Blood (435 Occurrences)

Obey (219 Occurrences)

Observe (216 Occurrences)

Circumcision: Necessity of, Asserted by False Teachers
Top of Page
Top of Page