In Job 39:13–17, the ostrich is depicted as neglecting her eggs; does modern scientific observation contradict this portrayal? Overview of the Ostrich in Job 39:13–17 Job 39:13–17 contains a vivid portrayal that raises the question of whether the ostrich truly neglects its eggs, as it might appear: • “The wings of the ostrich flap joyfully…” [Job 39:13] • “For she leaves her eggs on the ground and warms them in the dust…” [Job 39:14] • “…forgetting that a foot may crush them or a wild beast may trample them.” [Job 39:15] • “For God has deprived her of wisdom; He has not endowed her with understanding.” [Job 39:17] From these verses, some assume the Bible depicts the ostrich as an unintelligent bird that abandons its eggs. Modern science reveals more detail about ostrich behavior, but on closer study, there is no necessary contradiction between the biblical text and observed reality. Historical and Cultural Context The Book of Job dates to an ancient era—most scholars place it well before the New Testament period, with some evidence suggesting it is among the oldest poetic writings in Scripture. References to the ostrich here reflect firsthand observations from the general region of the Middle East and North Africa, where ostriches were once more commonly encountered. In the ancient world, authors like Aristotle (in “History of Animals”), Pliny the Elder (in “Natural History”), and various other naturalists made mention of ostriches. While often couched in myth or incomplete observations, these writings show that ostrich behavior could appear strange, especially compared to other birds. The biblical emphasis in Job 39:13–17 addresses this singular, somewhat puzzling aspect of ostrich habits. Modern Scientific Observations 1. Communal Nesting Ostriches typically engage in communal nesting. A dominant female frequently deposits her eggs in a central nest, sometimes alongside eggs from other females. Although it may appear that some eggs are being neglected—particularly when lesser females are forced to lay eggs around the periphery—this behavior ensures the most viable eggs remain in the safest spot. 2. Incubation Practices The temperature of the desert environment can provide considerable, natural warmth. During the day, adult ostriches may leave the nest for short periods; the substrate’s heat continues incubating the eggs. At night, either the male or the dominant female often covers the eggs more attentively. Although it may seem like neglect, the environment assists in the incubation process. 3. Risk of Predation Ostriches are large flightless birds that rely heavily on other survival tactics (speed, keen eyesight, and a formidable kick) to protect themselves and their offspring. Eggs on the outskirts of the communal nest can suffer from trampling or predation by jackals, hyenas, or other scavengers. This occasional loss of eggs reinforces the biblical statement that they are left vulnerable “on the ground” (Job 39:14) and at risk of trampling (Job 39:15). 4. Perceived “Lack of Wisdom” The verse stating that the ostrich is “deprived…of wisdom” (Job 39:17) can be read as poetic hyperbole about the bird’s unconventional or scattershot parenting style. Scientific studies on ostriches (e.g., University of Pretoria research on nest-site selection) show that, though ostriches exhibit strategic measures such as camouflage and communal care, these strategies can easily look like inattentiveness to casual observers—particularly in the wild where survival dynamics differ significantly from typical domesticated bird behaviors. Addressing Apparent Discrepancies 1. Poetic Emphasis vs. Literal Neglect Scripture often communicates through vivid imagery. Job 39 is a divinely delivered speech highlighting creatures that exhibit seeming contradictions or paradoxes. The passage emphasizes the ostensible recklessness of the ostrich, yet does not necessarily claim the bird never protects its eggs. Instead, it highlights the contrast between this bird’s behaviors and what humans might consider “wise” nest care. 2. Highlighting God’s Sovereignty Job 39:13–17 is part of a larger divine challenge emphasizing that human understanding is limited compared to the Creator’s. The fact that ostriches rely on different nesting methods, and sometimes leave eggs in open sight, underscores the complexity of creation. “She treats her young harshly…” (Job 39:16) can also be viewed in the context of communal nesting and pecking orders, rather than outright neglect. 3. Observational Consistency Modern field research does not contradict the essence of what is being emphasized. Ostriches do leave eggs on the ground, allow ambient heat to incubate them, and occasionally appear indifferent. Incidents of trampling occur, and non-dominant eggs can be pushed aside. Thus, no conflict arises between these biblical verses and modern observation when the poetic context and the communal nesting method of ostriches are accounted for. Comparative Notes and Interpretations • Similar Language in Ancient Texts: Other ancient records about ostriches also highlight seemingly bizarre behaviors (for example, references to burying heads in the sand, a myth that arose from their habit of lowering their heads close to the ground). These external texts similarly underline the ostrich’s unusual approaches to survival. • Poetry and Symbolism: Job contains Hebrew poetry that describes, in heightened form, creatures such as the leviathan, behemoth, horse, hawk, and eagle. Each is used to demonstrate divine wisdom. In the inspired composition, the ostrich plays a role as the bird that defies human expectations of “normal” maternal care. • Interpretive Lens: While the bird can be caring, the net impression to an onlooker—particularly in a harsh environment with threats from predators—can be that the mother bird is oblivious. Therefore, the biblical portrayal, when placed within its poetic and rhetorical setting, aligns with how an observer might see ostrich nesting strategies. Conclusion Modern science and observation of ostrich behaviors do not inherently contradict Job’s depiction. Rather, the biblical text focuses on behavior that superficially appears foolish or neglectful but is, in reality, part of the ostrich’s God-designed survival strategy. Communal nesting, dependence on natural heat, and occasional trampling or predation risk all create the impression of “neglect.” Yet research confirms that ostriches do incubate, guard, and tend their eggs in ways suited to their environment—reflecting the broader theme in Job that creation contains complexities beyond human wisdom. Far from a contradiction, the biblical description in Job resonates with the real (and occasionally mystifying) patterns of ostrich parenting. This passage highlights divine sovereignty and the marvels of living creatures, pointing readers toward deeper reverence rather than rigid literalism about all the bird’s daily routines. |
    |