What is cessationism? Definition of Cessationism Cessationism is a theological view that certain miraculous gifts—most notably the gifts of prophecy, tongues, and certain types of divine healings—ceased with the passing of the apostles and the close of the New Testament canon. Proponents believe God still works supernaturally and can providentially heal, but the specific sign gifts functioning as they did in the apostolic era are no longer operative in the same way today. This position hinges on the understanding that these miraculous signs were intended to authenticate the message of the apostles during the formation of the church (cf. Hebrews 2:3–4). Once the foundational period ended and Scripture was complete, these repeated manifestations of the sign gifts were no longer necessary. Key Biblical Evidence 1. The Cessation Language in 1 Corinthians 13 “Love never fails. But where there are prophecies, they will cease; where there are tongues, they will be restrained; where there is knowledge, it will be dismissed” (1 Corinthians 13:8). In this passage, the apostle Paul directly states that the gifts of prophecy and tongues will come to an end. Cessationists generally argue that this “end” arrived once the stage of establishing the church foundation concluded. While continuationists might view this “perfect” (verse 10) as Christ’s return, cessationists tend to link the phrase “then the imperfect passes away” with the close of the apostolic era or the completion of Scripture. 2. The Purpose of Signs in the Early Church Hebrews 2:3–4 points out that salvation “was first announced by the Lord, was confirmed to us by those who heard Him, and was affirmed by God through signs, wonders, various miracles, and gifts of the Holy Spirit distributed according to His will.” Cessationists find compelling evidence here: the signs and wonders were closely tied to the apostles’ ministry to confirm that they were genuine messengers of the Messiah during the church’s infancy. 3. Foundation Laid by the Apostles Ephesians 2:20 describes believers as “built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, with Christ Jesus Himself as the cornerstone.” Since the metaphor ties the apostles and prophets to the foundation of the church, cessationists argue that the “sign” ministries (prophecy, tongues, etc.) primarily authenticated that foundational work. Once laid, the emphasis shifts to building up individual believers and congregations through the teaching of established Scripture. Historical Perspective Historically, many early church leaders, such as John Chrysostom (4th century) and Augustine of Hippo (late 4th–5th century), noted in their writings that the gifts of tongues and prophecy had largely stopped within the broader church. In his “Homilies on 1 Corinthians,” Chrysostom commented on the rarity of the sign gifts in his day, suggesting that the normal operation of those particular gifts had largely ceased. Augustine, though his view seemed to shift later in life about certain miracle claims, often referred to apostolic-era miracles as being unique to that time. During and after the Protestant Reformation, influential theologians—such as John Calvin—argued that many miracle gifts were specific to the apostolic age. This perspective grew among various branches of Protestantism, leading to what is now commonly called the cessationist position. Arguments for Cessationism 1. The Close of Canon and the Role of Scripture Cessationists contend that once Scripture was completed, the authoritative revelation of God became fully inscripturated. Miraculous sign gifts primarily served to confirm new revelation. Since the biblical canon is closed, ongoing prophetic utterances would imply ongoing revelation, which cessationists view as unnecessary (and potentially contradictory to the sufficiency expressed in 2 Timothy 3:16–17). 2. Identification of Miracles in the Apostolic Era The New Testament era’s miraculous events—resurrections, instantaneous healings, and tongues—were neither ordinary nor continuous occurrences. Even the apostle Paul, late in his ministry, would leave Trophimus sick (2 Timothy 4:20)—suggesting that miraculous healings were less frequent. This shift indicates, for the cessationist, a special period of heightened miraculous occurrences primarily for laying the church’s foundation. 3. Authentication of Apostleship Signs and miracles were repeatedly associated with those in apostolic authority (cf. Acts 2:43; 5:12). Because only a specific number of apostles were chosen (Acts 1:22–26), the specialized signs confirming their office are viewed as unique to them and their immediate colleagues. The apostle Paul even defended his ministry with signs of a “true apostle” (2 Corinthians 12:12), and cessationists believe these unique markers ceased once that apostolic generation passed. 4. Early Church Father Corroboration Though not definitive in themselves, the writings of early church fathers show that the church universally recognized a diminishing frequency of the apostolic-type gifts post-first century. This observation aligns with the belief that God had a temporary purpose for these spectacular gifts. Common Objections and Responses 1. “God Is Unchanging—He Can Still Perform Miracles” Cessationists agree that God can and does perform miracles. However, they distinguish between unique sign gifts possessed by particular individuals and God’s ongoing power to answer prayer or intervene miraculously. While the miraculous activities in Scripture came at key redemptive-historical moments (exodus, prophetic eras, Jesus’ ministry, and the apostolic era), the cessationist view argues that the special offices and gifts from those defining epochs do not remain normative. 2. “1 Corinthians 13:10 Refers to Christ’s Future Return” Continuationists argue that the sign gifts will last until Christ’s return. As a counter, many cessationists see 1 Corinthians 13’s reference to the “perfect” (often interpreted as “completeness”) as the completed apostolic foundation, with Scripture now fulfilling the role of guiding and edifying believers. While this is a matter of debate, cessationists maintain that the immediate historical context and subsequent church history align with the position of gifts coming to an end. 3. “Modern Movements and Testimonies of Miraculous Gifts” Advocates of cessationism respond that many modern claims can be explained by psychological factors, linguistic phenomena, or events not verifiable as identical to the apostolic-era miracles. Furthermore, they emphasize the sufficiency of Scripture and the normal means God uses—through prayer, preaching, and providential help—to accomplish His will. Pastoral Implications Within churches identifying as cessationist, believers are encouraged to cherish the workings of the Holy Spirit in sanctification, conviction, and guiding the church through Scripture. They acknowledge that God answers prayers and that genuine miracles may still happen, but they view these occurrences as acts of God’s sovereignty rather than the normative exercise of a specific apostolic gift today. This perspective often shapes ministry practices—placing significant emphasis on expositional preaching, reliance on Scripture’s counsel, and discerning any claim of revelation or miraculous sign through the lens of biblical sufficiency. Conclusion Cessationism posits that the New Testament-era sign gifts served a temporary but critical role in establishing the church and authenticating the apostles. It underscores the closing of the biblical canon as the cessation point for revelatory and confirming gifts, while wholeheartedly affirming God’s ongoing ability to work supernaturally and answer prayer. Guided by scriptural mandates such as Hebrews 2:3–4, Mark 16:20, and 1 Corinthians 13:8, cessationists see the early New Testament miracles as foundational proofs of God’s message, intending future generations of believers to rely on the Word of God as the final authority. The cessationist approach continues to foster robust discussion and reflection within global Christianity, inviting believers to examine Scripture carefully and trust that God has provided everything needed for life and godliness in His revealed Word. |
    |