Proverbs 23:20–21 warns against drunkenness, yet other Scriptures permit moderate wine consumption; is this contradictory? Biblical Context of Wine and Drunkenness Wine appears throughout Scripture as both a gift and, at times, a source of danger. It is praised for its joyous qualities but also warned against when it leads to excessive indulgence or destructive behavior. Many ancient cultures, including those in biblical lands, relied on fermented beverages partly because the fermentation process purified water and provided refreshment in arid regions. Archaeological findings in present-day Israel, such as ancient winepresses and pottery containing wine residue, confirm that wine production was widespread and important in daily life. However, the question arises when comparing passages like Proverbs 23:20–21, which warns strongly against drunkenness, with certain passages that acknowledge or permit moderate wine consumption. At first glance, these verses might seem contradictory. A thorough look at the scriptural teaching, however, indicates unified principles rather than conflicting messages. Proverbs 23:20–21 in Focus Proverbs 23:20–21 reads: “Do not join those who drink too much wine or gorge themselves on meat. For the drunkard and the glutton will come to poverty, and drowsiness clothes them in rags.” The concern here is against a lifestyle characterized by overindulgence and a loss of self-control. The book of Proverbs, a collection of wisdom writings, repeatedly points out that a lack of discipline can lead to dire consequences—physically, financially, relationally, and spiritually. This guidance reflects practical wisdom: when a person is enslaved to alcohol, the ability to care for responsibilities and maintain God-honoring behavior rapidly deteriorates. Notably, these verses emphasize the dangers associated with drinking “too much” rather than forbidding the mere use of wine altogether. The core issue is the risk of becoming consumed by intoxication, which impairs judgment and often leads to wayward decisions. Scriptures That Allow Moderate Consumption Scripture also includes examples where wine is regarded positively: 1. Psalm 104:14–15 – Describes God as the One who “makes grass grow for the livestock and provides crops for man to cultivate, bringing forth food from the earth: wine that gladdens the heart of man….” Here, wine is acknowledged as part of God’s good provision. 2. 1 Timothy 5:23 – Paul advises Timothy, “No longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your stomach and your frequent ailments.” This suggests a permissible medical or practical use of wine for health reasons. 3. John 2:1–11 – At the wedding in Cana, Jesus turns water into wine. While the text does not explicitly comment on moderation, this record introduces Christ’s provision of wine in a celebratory context, indicating that the mere existence of wine at a wedding feast was culturally acceptable. These passages offer balance: wine itself is not presented as forbidden or inherently corrupt. Instead, it is the misuse or errant consumption that Scripture condemns. Consistency Across the Canon When weighed together, the principle is consistent: moderation is allowed, but excess is damaging. A range of early church fathers and later commentators recognized this distinction. Manuscript evidence from the earliest centuries also supports these passages, with no contradictions arising about whether wine itself is inherently evil or not. For instance, the compilation of the Dead Sea Scrolls (although predominantly focused on certain Old Testament manuscripts) and Greek manuscripts of the New Testament reveal consistent wording that upholds the same caution about intoxication and recognizes the legitimate role of moderate wine consumption. Over centuries of textual transmission, scribes meticulously copied the warnings and permissions related to wine without excessive editing or omission. The internal and external evidence surrounding these scriptural texts underscores the harmony of their message. Because of this, most conservative and critical scholars alike conclude there is no contradiction. Philosophical and Behavioral Considerations From a behavioral standpoint, alcohol’s capacity to alter one’s mental and emotional state necessitates caution. Scripture often highlights the human tendency toward addictive behaviors. Studies in behavioral science reveal that overuse of alcohol can harm cognitive function, strain relationships, and lead to other destructive habits. In light of this, the biblical texts encourage self-control—a fruit of a changed heart—demonstrating that the core concern is not the moderate consumption of wine, but rather the vulnerability to addiction and lack of restraint. The consistent injunction is to align one’s behavior with wisdom, seeking not only personal welfare but also the well-being of others who may be influenced negatively by displays of drunkenness. Reconciling the Apparent Tension 1. Warning vs. Moderation: Proverbs 23:20–21 strongly cautions against habitual drunkenness—an attitude that places selfish gratification above responsibility. Other passages that permit consuming wine assume control and gratitude, not chaos or recklessness. 2. Holistic Scriptural Teaching: The Bible, taken as a whole, recognizes that certain created things (including wine) have good uses when enjoyed within wise boundaries. It is not contradictory but situational, much like other areas of life—food, work, rest—where moderation honors God and excess leads to detrimental outcomes. 3. Practical Implications: The prohibition is against “too much” wine and a gluttonous lifestyle that undermines good stewardship of resources and personal discipline. Conversely, moderate enjoyment of God’s gifts is viewed as a blessing when it does not dominate one’s life or violate conscience. Conclusion Proverbs 23:20–21, with its sober warning against drunkenness, harmonizes seamlessly with passages that note the beneficial and permissible use of wine under controlled circumstances. Rather than signaling a biblical contradiction, these verses collectively paint a consistent picture: wine, like many of God’s provisions, can be a source of joy when used wisely, yet becomes destructive when misused. For centuries, believers have discovered that approaching these teachings in balance guards against legalistic extremes on one hand and irresponsibility on the other. The biblical invitation is to exercise self-control, gratitude, and stewardship. Understood correctly, these passages offer a timeless, unified message about how to handle God’s gifts for one’s own well-being and to honor the One who ultimately provides every good thing. |
    |